Discussion about this post

User's avatar
William Brondt Kamffer's avatar

So, I have to push back a little here (I will reserve final judgement until the series has ended--and maybe you address my concern in future posts): The problem with the word "anxiety" is that it is rather flexible (not unlike "love"). In the Sermon, I think Christ is talking about the sort of anxiety that affects everyone in their day-to-day life, the sort of anxiety that says, "How am I going to pay rent next month?" or "Can we afford to have kids?" These are very much in the vein of choosing between trusting in God or trusting in Mammon. Neither, I think, are what modern psychiatry means by "anxiety" (though psychological anxiety can certainly manifest in these sorts of worries too).

I'm sure, given your experience, that you have seen those people who are simply unable to control their anxiety, even by "trusting in God." As someone for whom this is a struggle, literally everything in my life is a source of anxiety. Does my wife love me? Am I going to get fired today? Am I going to die painfully in a car wreck on the one-mile drive to the grocery store? Is this chicken going to make me sick? And so on.

While there is definitely a need to trust in God even in these things, it is distinctly different than the ordinary focused sources of anxiety that strike the average person. The psychological anxiety is so overwhelming as to cause paralysis, panic attacks, and deep (almost suicidal) depression. Drugs do not fix the problem, to be sure, but they suppress the anxiety enough that a person can get a handle on it and actually trust in God.

In the grip of such anxiety, not only is it impossible to trust in God, it is impossible even to believe that God cares for us at all.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts